Friday, September 7, 2012

Replicating Video Game Motivation




The Digital World and Its Effects On Motivation

Part 1:  Analyzing Video Game's



Lets Start our analysis off with two simple images here, and I will let you be the judge.  The following images are from the video game of video games, the great Mario it's self

Level 1


This is one of the very first levels of the Mario video games and it goes to show the very reason people love to play video games.  Level one, as the picture depicts looks extremely basic as it should be!  If you are in the business of motivating people, video games have hammered that nail since they started.  The key to motivation is keeping people interested with a set of challenges that increase in difficulty as one progresses through the task.  Even if you have never played Mario, you would have a good chance at beating this level.  There are no enemies, and there are no hidden tricks.  In this level you simply jump Luigi around hitting the little boxes to get coins before you jump to the next screen.  A perfect start!  When I start a task, I want something that is low risk and high reward.  Once my Luigi is hopping around this area, I am picking up coins, hearing that little bounce sound, and ooo'ing and aahhhing at the scenery.  This provides a key "safe" environment that is going to prepare me for what's ahead...



A Later Level.



       Look at the difference we have here!  Imagine starting your video game experience off here, instead of the level one picture above.  Do you notice those holes in the bottom ground? Yea, when you accidentally fall through, that will cost you one life.  What we have here is an example of high risk/higher reward.  This level hands down is going to be challenging, if this is your first time playing Mario you are in for a long haul, after a few lives lost you'll begin to question why you bought this game, Why cant I just easily get from tier to tier without dying. Can this task really be that hard???!?!?!?!  This is where your motivation can and will plummet.  Maybe if at this point, you had some prior experience of the happy Luigi at level one. You would be biting your lip, and feeling the adrenaline kick in as every time you play through this level you get "a little closer"  


How much is a little closer?

       Here is where the brilliance of video games out trumps our current education system 1000x over.  If you cant beat level one in a video game, you cannot, I repeat, cannot move to level 2 UNTIL you have completed level one.  Simple. No Tricks. Complete Motivation.  This is where video games win every time, and its not like Mario is the only popular game in the $18.5 Billion industry. The second you experience the "a little closer," feeling you are hooked.  At this point, your brain is loving the rewards and the increasing difficulty of the challenges.  The second you master a level you are onto the next challenge with the wind of the past challenge still fresh, and pushing you onward.  Every time you see the level complete sign, you are granted with instant feedback of a job well done.  Once the motivation ball gets rolling here, its hard to stop.  Even if there is suddenly a huge difficulty ramp up, you have already built so much motivation and confidence that is worth multiple tries at completing a hard level.

Another way of thinking about it.

       If you cant jump your Luigi around a couple blocks and a green tube(picture 1) Then how can you realistically expect to magically complete the complex layout of level 2(second picture).  It does not make sense.  However, on the other side, if you complete level one then you have shown that you can jump Luigi and aim his jump to certain areas.  By completing level one, you have shown mastery in the skills necessary for level 2.  White this setup may sound basic, it is a solid approach.  Unfortunately,  this structure is completely lacking in the current education system.  Let's take a look at how our current math curriculum handles this problem.




"Dude that Math Boss Level Was SO HARD"



              Lets do some good old comparing and contrasting of the motivation of video games, to the current method of teaching math.  We will start here with the first standard(Common Core) for 6th grade Math.

6.RP.1. Understand the concept of a ratio and use ratio language to describe a ratio relationship between two quantities. For example, “The ratio of wings to beaks in the bird house at the zoo was 2:1, because for every 2 wings there was 1 beak.” “For every vote candidate A received, candidate C received nearly three votes.” 

Your math curriculum starts out right just like we analysed in the video games.  Here we start with a basic task, that we are going to build on in the unit.  And so the teacher starts out with the tutorial on how to do the problem.  Maybe the teacher well then show a sample problem or two before setting the class loose on a worksheet for the last thirty minutes of the lesson

.  The above setup for a math lesson is about as common as it gets.  You rarely have math classes differ from this method.  So after the students get the worksheet, here comes the problem.  

TYPICAL MATH WORKSHEET

Here is an example of a typical math worksheet.  Most math work sheets end up following this method.  It starts out with basic problems that you calculate, then moves onto a different part of calculating the problem, and then almost every math sheet always ends with that word problem, you know, to put you in Bob The Painters shoes and how hes going to use math to fix that dang problem.

             This absolutely breaks the number one rule of video games, You do not go to level two, UNTIL you are done with level one.  I have watched hundreds of math lessons that break this rule.  We give the kids a basic tutorial, and then turn them loose on a worksheet that is sure to confuse them with difficult word problems.  At the same time, the teacher just paces around the room helping each individual student until the time is up and then the papers are turned in.  Is it to any shock, that when we follow this method we get a ton of students that maybe got the first part right, but then fail to understand the rest of the worksheet.  Even worse, I have seen to many lessons where more than half of the class fails the entire worksheet.  This is where the students motivation absolutely plummets.  They are given a massive worksheet, with very little reinforcement along the way.  In following this method, you will get your kids to hate math and risk killing all of their motivation.

Taking one from the great book of Video Games:

         
     What if we took the basic foundation of a video games motivational success, and then applied it our math curriculum.  Lets take that same worksheet and apply some videogame-ology(I love making words up) to it.


LEVEL 1: PREPARE TO MEET THY RULER

This would be the first thing I would give my students after completing our lesson/tutorial on the subject.  Lets take a note of a few things here.

1)  When you hand this out to the students, you immediatly dispel the "WAHTTTT HUGEE WORKSHEET AGAIN????? OOO NOOO MR JOHNSON"  Instead, we give them the level one segment of our worksheet. The fear of the worksheet goes down, and the chance of a motivating success goes up

2)  Without showing the students the other parts of the worksheet here, we give them only one thing to work on.  A simple goal of finishing these three basic problems first is that "first level of the video game experience," That our students need to drive them to the "A little closer" feeling that we want them to have.

With that said, you can now announce to your students that level one has begun.  Let the students get to work and help them with any questions along the way.

Once you give them time to complete level 1, then have the students turn in the little slip.  Here is where you can get a good taste of which students are understanding the lesson and which ones are not.  Now that we have broken the lesson down here, it becomes much easier for that student that maybe gets it wrong on the first try.  Give them some help and have them return Level one in so they can start Level two.  You will also see a huge rise in motivation once the students complete Level one.  And if you do the lesson right, the students will be begging you for Level two.  The students will be eager for what level two will be like and how hard it will be.

LEVEL 2: FIND THE PERIMETER YOU MUST!


Only give the students the next level when they have completed level 1, do not break the rule of video games!  After we give them level two, your students should have some motivation on the topic.  They now feel that sense of mastery.  You'll hear things like "man level 1 was easy," "level one was a good challenge, is level two even harder?"  Now you have the students hooked, and their motivation is rising.  You need to   rinse and repeat here.  Have the students turn in Level two and if they complete Level two, then you can move them on to level three.

LEVEL 3: THE BOSS LEVEL


No Video game is complete without the boss level.  There's no point to playing Mario, if you don't face Bowser.  Students love having the ultimate challenge, the end of the road showdown.  Luckily, this is the part of math that we want students to understand because the word problems and unique problems are what build strong mathematical foundations.  Tell the students we are entering level three the Boss level.  Rinse and Repeat again.  Have the students keep turning in level three until they have passed the level.

If your students can pass level three, would you not say they are ready for the next step in this unit?  When students can complete all three levels and can demonstrate the mastery, you should then be able to move onto the next unit much easier instead of moving onto the next unit because 6.1 was yesterday.....


CONCLUSION:

In conclusion, video games have really hit the nail hard when it comes to motivation.  Continuous streaks of low risk/high reward that build into high risk/higher reward establish good foundations for new skills that a student is learning.  In the end the motivation of the student will keep them fighting for the solution of the next unit and so on.










  






Monday, September 3, 2012

An Introduction

Welcome to the Education Through Motivation Blog.

This blog is going to be focusing on the vital link between Education and how it is obtained through motivation.  All learning is derived from some sense of motivation whether it is a extrinsic or intrinsic factor.  At the same time everyone has weak and strong levels of motivation towards the multitude of different challenges we face every day.  When I wake up tired, and I know that some coffee is obtainable, you have already put the image in your mind of what I will be doing next.  When I find that my reading reflection for a college course is due in 2 weeks on chapters 1 and 2, you have already put that on the back burner in your mind as well.  Shifting away from the early adult/adolescent brain.  This blog will focus on a K-6 level of motivation which leads to many different aspects of motivation and detaild.

Enough of the scientific reasoning blabber for now.  Here are some big questions I am hoping to gain a better understanding of.

1)  How do digital worlds and story's(fancy way of saying video games/internet huh?) completely overcome (I am talking about that night where you know the work NEEDS to be done, yet before you know it you are checking your social media, or are logging into your MMO game, When you easily could of spent the 2 hours to get your work done, then proceeded to entertain yourself) the process of completing homework and real life tasks.  What Motivational factors are beating you to play video games/social media over your teacher?  You know the homework is due tomorrow, you know the consequence firm and clear.  If you ask me, these are some very intense motivational factors that are winning you over in a digital world instead of the real world.

2)  How can we analyse and test the small details of motivation.  Movement, a unique topic that the class is passionate about, ETC.  Obviously if our school assignments were to log 2 hours of Call of Duty MFW3 Mon-Friday, We would have quite the high homework grades.  Instead, as educators we need to find the happy medium, a lesson that motivates and keeps the level of interest while hitting the goal of any lesson.... to understand and retain the knowledge.

3)  Why do kids hate school?  This is the king-pin of education through Motivation, I have heard the statement to many times now "Whats your favorite subject"  ......... "Recess of course."  I want kids to be excited about playing dont get me wrong, but I also want kids to be motivated, I want to hear "I love science, it really links me to how the world works, I could see myself doing that one day as a job"  Motivation is everything here, somewhere along the line a student turns the table over and makes the decision that they do not like school.  You'll notice at any school that it is very hard to find a kindergartner that says "I hate school"  
With these students we need to understand what has happened and as educators we must strive to re-motivate them.

4) Why is it that.. You can ask anybody who has went to school who there favorite teacher was and.... instantly they light up like a Christmas tree and start telling you all about how Mr.Johnsons class was AMAZING, we did this, we even did that!, We did this too!!!  Compare that to asking someone about the "other" teachers and suddenly, oh well in that class... yea it was just... uhmmm...     A huge piece of motivation through Education is likely to lie here.

These are some of the starting questions, I will be researching in this blog, before I leave here, let me tell you a bit about myself


I am Andrew Auten 24, from Phoenix, Arizona.  My call to education came as I graduated high school and began teaching Chess as an after school program at various schools.  I had never worked with kids before, but I had a deep love for the game and decided to get paid for something that I was already motivated about.  Later on, I decided to major in education.  I recently graduated ASU, and I am currently working full time as a Chess coach at after school programs for kids.  The inspiration for this blog came from many past experiences of my childhood, my current career, and the huge differences I have experienced/seen from the many educators I have learned from/know.


-ANDREW